Exam Cram Question

I am going through some questions from the Exam Cram book, and ran into this
one that makes no sense. To me, nothing is required on Server2 because the
IP address for printer1 does not lie within its scope.

Can someone tell me what I am missing here?




Your network consists of a single Active Directory domain. All serveres run
Windows Server 2003 SP2. The network contains two servers named Server1 and
Server2.

Server1 is configured as a DHCP server and has a scope that contains
addresses 192.168.2.51 through 192.168.2.125.

You have a reservation for a printer named Printer1. The reservation
assigned address 192.168.2.100.

You install DHCP on Server2 and create a scope that contains addresses
192.168.2.126 to 192.168.2.200.

You need to ensure that Printer1's IP address always remains the same

What should you create on Server2?

A) Exclusion range
B) Reservation
C) Supercope
A) User class

Buck Turgidson wrote:
> I am going through some questions from the Exam Cram book, and ran into this
> one that makes no sense. To me, nothing is required on Server2 because the
> IP address for printer1 does not lie within its scope.
>
> Can someone tell me what I am missing here?

The answer is B:

When the Printer is looking for an IP address it will Broadcast its
request.

Both DHCP servers will respond to the request.

Server1 will respond with the Reservation you've created
Server2 will respond with an IP address from its lease range

The Printer will take the first response it receives and use that. That
means that you won't find the printer if the address came from Server2
(because the address isn't the one you expect).

When dealing with a split scope in DHCP it is extremely important that
you duplicate any reservation information. Both servers must be prepared
to give a client with a reservation the same address.

Remember that the client device has no idea what IP address it's
supposed to use, so the fact that the address you want it to use is
within the scope on Server1 is not actually relevant.

Finally, it is quite common to find that Reservations are leased from
excluded ranges (split scope or not). I do, in part because the reserved
addresses are used in firewall rules and I like to keep things nice and
clear.

HTH

Chris

When dealing with a split scope in DHCP it is extremely important that
> you duplicate any reservation information. Both servers must be prepared
> to give a client with a reservation the same address.
>
> Remember that the client device has no idea what IP address it's supposed
> to use, so the fact that the address you want it to use is within the
> scope on Server1 is not actually relevant.
>
> Finally, it is quite common to find that Reservations are leased from
> excluded ranges (split scope or not). I do, in part because the reserved
> addresses are used in firewall rules and I like to keep things nice and
> clear.
>


Extremely helpful info. Thanks!!!