Malke, the only difference between an XP upgrade cd and a Vista dvd using an
upgrade product key is that the XP upgrade cd will require a disk swap
during the shiny media check. Its the impossibility of doing a disk swap in
the middle of setup that prevents XP upgrade cds from being usable.
As you no doubt know, Mac optical drives do not have any sort of mechanical
means to eject a disc. Since the Mac keyboard Eject key is not enabled
until after XP is completely installed and the Mac keyboard driver
installed, there is no way during XP setup to eject a disc.
The reason the keyless installation worked with Vista on a Mac is that no
disc ejection is involved until Vista installation has completed.
The inablility to complete the shiny media check is the only problem with
using an XP upgrade cd.
"Malke" <> wrote in message
news:et%23%...
> Sinner wrote:
>
>>
>> "Malke" <> wrote in message
>> news:Ob9$...
>>> none wrote:
>>>
>>>
>>> Yes, as long as the Vista install disk is a full Retail one, not an
>>> upgrade.
>>
>> Wrong! I just did a clean install with an upgrade disc. Of course, you
>> have to install it twice. The first time without the Key, but it does
>> work.
>
> Onto a Mac? If you were able to install an upgrade version of Vista onto
> an
> Intel Mac, then I bow to your superior experience and admit I'm wrong. If
> you haven't actually tried this, then I will go with what Apple says here:
>
> http://docs.info.apple.com/article.h.../en/11889.html
>
> "Important: You must use a single full-install Windows installation disc.
> Service pack 2 is required for Windows XP installations. Do not install an
> earlier version of Windows XP and attempt to update it later to service
> pack 2. Use only 32-bit versions of Windows."
>
> So if you have really used an upgrade version of Vista to install onto
> your
> Intel Mac using Boot Camp, please post back with the details of how you
> did
> it so I can add this to my notes.
>
> Thank you.
>
> Malke
> --
> MS-MVP
> Elephant Boy Computers - Don't Panic!
> FAQ - http://www.elephantboycomputers.com/#FAQ
>