Bill Kearney <> wrote:
>> We need to set up a Windows 2003 as a print server and the printers
>> are shared on WinXP Workstations.
>> There are no Active Directory Server.
>
> Ok, here's the important question, why do you want to do this?
>
> Each workstation sharing a printer has it's own print spooler running.
>
> What would a central print spooler do for you? What problem are you
> looking to solve?
I can't answer for the OP but a central print server is nice when you want
to centrally manage your printers.
>
>> Then, I shared that printer on the server and mapped from another
>> workstation. When i send a print job, I get error 5, Access denied on
>> Event view.
>
> I'm guessing it has everything to do with not using Active Directory.
I don't think so. It really sounds like the printer in question is not being
installed as a local printer on the W2003 server - he was trying to re-share
a *network* printer.
> When using AD you have the ability for services (like the spooler) to
> make use of permissions that are shared and accessible across all
> machines joined to the domain. When you use only workstation
> security it becomes a big hassle trying to make sure each user and
> service has the right credentials needed to access the resources.
Yes, but I'm presuming he has security configured such that the workstation
users can access shared *data* folders on the server already. It can be
done. It sucks, and I agree that AD is nearly always a good fit, but this
can be done.
> The trouble is "userA" on "workstationA" isn't the same as "userA" on
> "workstationB", nor are any groups setup that way. You have a real
> housekeeping nightmare trying to make sure each "user" and "group"
> contains the correct one. When you use AD that housekeeping is done
> for you. You can setup a share and tell it which groups have access
> and be done with it. No additional housekeeping is necessary when
> you create new users or change their passwords.
Amen, brother.
>
> For what reasons are you not running a domain?
>
> -Bill Kearney
|