Is WMP11 any good for Classical Music?

Discussion in 'Windows Media Player' started by Keke, May 21, 2007.

  1. Keke

    Keke Guest

    I still use WMP10 because I have a large library, of which about half is of
    classical music. WMP10 says I have 14,564 items at 101.83 GB.

    I confess to getting infuriated by the assumption that all music are "songs"
    or "tunes" or even "tracks" when I want to organise my music into
    "movements", "acts" or by "Opus No." and have specific places for
    descriptions such as "allegro", "adagio" etc. I have spent a long time on my
    WMP 10 library , and although not ideal, it is in a fair shape.

    I read a lot of bad comments regarding WMP 11 on these boards aand resist
    the "upgrade" dialogue box that periodically appears. Frankly, I am fearful
    of upgrading to WMP 11 because of what it might do to my library.

    But have there been improvements? Have their been updates that have
    addressed the early complaints? And is it any good for lovers of classical
    music?
     
    Keke, May 21, 2007
    #1
    1. Advertisements

  2. Like you I have a large collection (45,000 songs) of which about 5,000 are
    classical music pieces. Been using WMP 11 for about a year - since the Beta
    came out. Bottom line, I've been more disappointed than pleased. As for your
    Classical music issues, they're not really addressed with the new WMP 11
    version.

    Here's a thumbnail of my observations about WMP 11....I've since loaded
    RealPlayer which solves most of the issues that I have.

    Positives
    * Better, more robust searching capabilities
    * I like that the album artwork is linked into the library more intuitively

    Negatives
    * You lose the ability to quickly see how many tracks/memory/total play time
    you have selected in any particular screen. You'd think this would be a
    no-brainer;
    * Won't work easily with iPod. Not sure if this is a MSFT or Apple-driven
    issue based on the periodic software upgrades from Apple
    * A huge pain - I'm just discovering a new problem...my music library is
    getting indexed differently by WMP 11 depending on the machine I use. For
    instance, my total colection is about 45K songs. My laptop version of WMP11
    only indexes about 33K songs. My desktop indexes about 30K. I can still play
    the remaining tracks, buyt have to load them manually song by song.
     
    Claude S. Weiller, May 21, 2007
    #2
    1. Advertisements

  3. Keke

    Doug Guest

    Stay with WMP10. WMP11 will not improve your life one iota.
    -
    Doug W.
    -
     
    Doug, May 21, 2007
    #3
  4. Keke

    Keke Guest

    This is very disappointing. Can anyone suggest an alternative? For instance,
    if I keep my rock (etc) music in one folder, which WMP uses, and put my
    classical music in another folder which WMP does not access, and use another
    player for just classical. Which other player is best for classical music?
    Any ideas? Any experience?
     
    Keke, May 22, 2007
    #4
    1. Advertisements

Ask a Question

Want to reply to this thread or ask your own question?

You'll need to choose a username for the site, which only take a couple of moments (here). After that, you can post your question and our members will help you out.